Pixel 8a vs P1 5G

Phone 1

Phone 2

Winner

Google Pixel 8a

Lifespan decides this one: the Pixel 8a is supported until May 2031 at $5.10 per month of safe use, while the P1 5G runs out in Apr 2028 ($7.53/month). On a which-lasts-longer question, that's not a tie — it's the whole answer.

Value Score: Pixel 8a 77 · P1 5G 67 — methodology

The lifespan decider

When specs are close, support length decides it — this is what each phone costs per month of safe use.

Google Pixel 8a $300

Safe to buy$5.10/mo

2024◆ Buy-by May 20292031

Realme P1 5G $165

Buy with care$7.53/mo

2024◆ Buy-by Apr 20262028

Category by category

Display

Pixel 8a 70P1 5G 70

Both displays are effectively the same class.

Performance

Pixel 8a 70P1 5G 52

The Pixel 8a's Google Tensor G3 is simply the faster chip.

Camera

Pixel 8a 67P1 5G 55

The Pixel 8a has the stronger camera system (2 real rear lenses vs 1).

Battery

Pixel 8a 70P1 5G 80

5,000mAh vs 4,492mAh — the P1 5G lasts longer between charges.

Software longevity

Pixel 8a 70P1 5G 26

The Pixel 8a is supported until May 2031 — 37 months longer than the P1 5G.

Value

Pixel 8a 77P1 5G 67

Overall value goes to the Pixel 8a at $5.10 per month of safe use.

Full spec table

Spec	Pixel 8a	P1 5G
Price (street)	$300	$165
Display	6.1-inch Actua OLED, FHD+, 60–120Hz, up to 2000 nits peak	6.67-inch AMOLED, FHD+, 120Hz, up to 2000 nits peak
Chipset	Google Tensor G3	MediaTek Dimensity 7050 (6nm)
RAM	8GB	6GB/8GB
Storage	128GB/256GB	128GB/256GB
Battery	4,492 mAh	5,000 mAh
Charging	18W wired, 7.5W wireless	45W wired
Rear cameras	64MP main, 13MP ultra-wide	50MP main, 2MP depth
Dimensions	152.1 × 72.7 × 8.9 mm	165.7 × 76 × 7.9 mm
Weight	188 g	190 g
Water resistance	IP67	IP54
Supported until	May 2031	Apr 2028

Pixel 8a full verdict →P1 5G full verdict →Longevity master board →

Scores and verdicts are computed from our verified database — see exactly how. Specs from manufacturer documentation; prices reflect major US retailers.